diff --git a/pr_template_filled.md b/pr_template_filled.md deleted file mode 100644 index 3882d80..0000000 --- a/pr_template_filled.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,99 +0,0 @@ -## PR Title Format - -**fix: Fix o3-pro empty response issue by using output_text field** - -## Description - -This PR fixes a critical bug where o3-pro API calls were returning empty responses. The root cause was incorrect response parsing - the code was trying to manually parse `response.output.content[]` array structure, but o3-pro provides a simpler `output_text` convenience field directly on the response object. This PR also introduces a secure HTTP recording system for testing expensive o3-pro calls. - -## Changes Made - -- [x] Fixed o3-pro response parsing by using the `output_text` convenience field instead of manual parsing -- [x] Added `_safe_extract_output_text` method with proper validation to handle o3-pro's response format -- [x] Implemented custom HTTP transport recorder to replace respx for more reliable test recordings -- [x] Added comprehensive PII sanitization to prevent accidental API key exposure in test cassettes -- [x] Sanitized all existing test cassettes to remove any exposed secrets -- [x] Updated documentation for the new testing infrastructure -- [x] Added test suite to validate the fix and ensure PII sanitization works correctly - -**No breaking changes** - The fix only affects o3-pro model parsing internally. - -**Dependencies added:** -- None (uses existing httpx and standard library modules) - -## Testing - -### Run all linting and tests (required): -```bash -# Activate virtual environment first -source venv/bin/activate - -# Run comprehensive code quality checks (recommended) -./code_quality_checks.sh - -# If you made tool changes, also run simulator tests -python communication_simulator_test.py -``` - -- [x] All linting passes (ruff, black, isort) -- [x] All unit tests pass -- [x] **For bug fixes**: Tests added to prevent regression - - `test_o3_pro_output_text_fix.py` - Validates o3-pro response parsing works correctly - - `test_o3_pro_http_recording.py` - Tests HTTP recording functionality - - `test_pii_sanitizer.py` - Ensures PII sanitization works properly -- [x] Manual testing completed with realistic scenarios - - Verified o3-pro calls return actual content instead of empty responses - - Validated that recorded cassettes contain no exposed API keys - -## Related Issues - -Fixes o3-pro API calls returning empty responses on master branch. - -## Checklist - -- [x] PR title follows the format guidelines above -- [x] **Activated venv and ran code quality checks: `source venv/bin/activate && ./code_quality_checks.sh`** -- [x] Self-review completed -- [x] **Tests added for ALL changes** (see Testing section above) -- [x] Documentation updated as needed - - Updated `docs/testing.md` with new testing approach - - Added `docs/vcr-testing.md` for HTTP recording documentation -- [x] All unit tests passing -- [x] Ready for review - -## Additional Notes - -### The Bug: -On master branch, o3-pro API calls were returning empty responses because the code was trying to parse the response incorrectly: -```python -# Master branch - incorrect parsing -if hasattr(response.output, "content") and response.output.content: - for content_item in response.output.content: - if hasattr(content_item, "type") and content_item.type == "output_text": - content = content_item.text - break -``` - -The o3-pro response object actually provides an `output_text` convenience field directly: -```python -# Fixed version - correct parsing -content = response.output_text -``` - -### The Fix: -1. Added `_safe_extract_output_text` method that properly validates and extracts the `output_text` field -2. Updated the response parsing logic in `_generate_with_responses_endpoint` to use this new method -3. Added proper error handling and validation to catch future response format issues - -### Additional Improvements: -- **Testing Infrastructure**: Implemented HTTP transport recorder to enable testing without repeated expensive API calls -- **Security**: Added automatic PII sanitization to prevent API keys from being accidentally committed in test recordings - -### Development Notes: -- During development, we encountered timeout issues with the initial respx-based approach which led to implementing the custom HTTP transport recorder -- The transport recorder solution properly handles streaming responses and gzip compression - -### For Reviewers: -- The core fix is in `providers/openai_compatible.py` lines 307-335 and line 396 -- The HTTP transport recorder is test infrastructure only and doesn't affect production code -- All test cassettes have been sanitized and verified to contain no secrets \ No newline at end of file